Back on December 5, 2025, I covered how the Henderson Castle was sued by a customer. A customer alleges that Andrea Toliver left multiple 1-star reviews in retaliation for the customer’s 1-star Google review of the Henderson Castle. Google placed a consumer alert warning that Suspicious high-rated reviews were recently removed from this place. I first saw this warning with City Farm Roslindale Weed Dispensary back on June 25, 2025. At that time, they were unable to receive new reviews for one month. The warning remained for one month as well. Google has now increased the warning period and the inability to get new reviews to 2 months.
Currently, the Henderson Castle isn’t showing any Google reviews or a rating. I am not sure whether this is working as intended or part of a bug. People have reported that all of their Google reviews went missing after they flagged a review for removal. We will have to wait and see if any of the reviews come back.
It’s been alleged that this is the second time that the Henderson Castle has recieved this warning. If this is true, this is alarming. This is the only time I have heard of a business being warned twice.